• Science
    • Planetary Material Conditions
    • Society
    • Politics
    • Doom
    • Doom Philosophy
    • Solutions
    • General category
    • Revolution
  • Move
  • Topic
  • Back
  • Next

    Why the World is Going Insane, from umair haque

    Started by Knarf Sep 24, 2023, 05:30 AM

    Message path : / Doom Philosophy / Doom literacy / Why the World is Going Insane, from umair haque


    Selected path :

    • Posts: 0
    • No IP found (?)
    Sep 24, 2023, 05:30 AM
    I became a member of "Medium". There is this guy whom I follow because I think he gets it. Here is his latest "rant".

    It strikes me these days, as it probably strikes you, that the world has gone a little crazy, has lost its bearings. It struck me recently, along those lines, that "insane" is, funnily, a near perfect acronym for the links in the causal chain, the vicious cycle, that country after country is falling prey to. That we as a world are falling prey to. The one leading us into a dark age of extremists, authoritarians, kleptocrats, and throngs cheering it all along.

    So. Here we go.

    IN stands for inequality. It's the prime mover of today's problems. Inequality within countries has skyrocketed — and that's in every country around the globe, more or less, even well-managed ones, like Canada and Sweden. As inequality jumps, social distance grows. Rich and poor share little in common — not schools, roads, hospitals, and so on — and so a society begins to corrode from within — it loses trust. Politics grow polarized. The civic sphere corrodes. Decent jobs turn into minimum wage gigs, and becoming a CEO turns into a lottery ticket for a fortune that will last generations. Any sense of higher, enduring values decays, degenerates, and everything becomes about money, money, money. As we will see, what is lost when inequality grows is dignity, stability, opportunity, gentleness — a sense, in the end, that a society is a worthy, healthy, vibrant place.

    S: Stagnation and stratification. Over time, as societies become more unequal places, economies — and the lives within them — begin to stagnate. That is because the lion's share of gain are going to the already very rich — as in America, for example, where over the last two decades, almost all gains have accrued to the top .01%. As stagnation sets in, a healthy nation's social structure begins to fracture, buckle, collapse. A "middle class," to which anyone can ascend , belong, and stay a part of — key to a vibrant democracy, a sense of optimism, a society that coheres and hangs together, a country that is not a hostile and cruel and indifferent place — becomes a new poor. The old poor become the wretched. And rich become the dynastic. For anyone but the richest, lives of dignity, meaning, purpose, belonging become unaffordable luxuries.

    A: Austerity and authoritarianism. What usually happens next is this: the average person, having become the newly impoverished one, falls prey to a myth of folk economics: "because I am going bankrupt, we must be going bankrupt!" And so up spout MSNBC pundits and crackpot economists, who warn a nation of impending financial ruin, when precisely the opposite is true: a nation can't go bankrupt, only people can, and for precisely that reason, stagnant economies are the ones that demand investment most — and can't have it, because money is piled up at the top, usually in colossal amounts, which is what caused slowdowns to begin with — remember? Money is abundant in stagnant economies — it is only stoppered up in all the wrong places.

    But usually the folk myth wins — demanding belt-tightening, because they are growing poorer, people say: "less government spending!" — and do not understand that just means: "I don't want my neighbours to invest in me!" And so there go public healthcare, media, finance, infrastructure — there go safety nets, retirements, decent jobs. But as they go, that newly impoverished person grows poorer still — because all those could have raised their income, savings, standard of living. All those things could have restored the lost belonging, meaning, purpose, sense of worthiness that people have lost, and hunger desperately for. But they have denied themselves.

    So the average person is baffled. Nothing works! He or she loses what little trust they had in the system, themselves, the future, their society. Despair and rage grow hot and heavy in their hearts. What can they do? Now they are easy meat for authoritarians. And usually, the average person seeks safety in the arms of the first one who comes along, shouting and screaming.

    N and E stand for nationalism and extremism. What does the authoritarian do to fix this mess — a society whose social structure has collapsed from the middle, an economy that needs investment but can't get it, and people who have been told exactly the wrong things to do about it all?

    Well, the first thing authoritarians usually do is enact aggressive nationalisms."This land! It is ours!" they bellow. Substitute "land" for healthcare, finance, jobs, or trade, and the story remains the same. So authoritarianism is a way to ration dwindling prosperity — if you are of pure blood, from the right tribe, and so on, you can have a piece of the shrinking pie. But the problem remains that the pie is shrinking in the first place — and so where once there is a soft nationalism, usually, a decade or two later, there is a hard, vengeful, cruel one, in which yesterday's fortunate are today's unwanted. That is the story of Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany both.

    So nationalism soon enough becomes extremism, because rationing a shrinking pie leads nowhere but to a Lord of the Flies plight. And that is where this cycle ends — with nations teetering on the brink of hostility, war, violence. Usually, they descend headlong, enthusiastically, into it.

    Now. Let us discuss what my little INSANE framework (lol) really means.

    You are right if you already suspect it was the story of the 1930s. But there is more to it than that. It was also the story of Rome's fall. It was the story of Athens' descent into tyranny. It is how the Maya and Inca fell, too. The only differences in these are the initial triggers of inequality and stagnation — was it some kind of foolish human choice, hubris, as in Rome? Was it natural calamity, as for the Maya and Inca? Or was it famine and drought, as in Athens? This is a universal pattern of how human organizations — the biggest ones, societies — fall apart.

    Ours? It'll be the calamities brought on by climate change — better called Extinction. So the question for societies, and people, today is this: which ones will be able to see the pattern before it is too late? After all, seeing a pattern gives one power not to repeat it, to understand it, to try, at least, to prevent it.

    Let's think about that for a moment. Media and intelligentsia across the world are denying each and every link of the pattern above. According to them, authoritarianism, nationalism, and extremism, are just the results of...bad people. Ah — already you see how easily the pattern above provokes hostility? How it reduces us to ignorance?

    Of course, the ANE in INSANE cannot just be the result of bad people, because they are problems suddenly sweeping the globe. A few bad apples cannot be causing the ANE to rise and prosper, from Britain to Italy to Sweden to Hungary to India. But too many thinkers refuse outright to think about the world even in basic ways like doing global comparisons anymore.

    Now. That tells us something vital. We might not make it out of the cycle at the rate we're going. If you can't see it, you can't stop it, remember? And people are not shown this cycle much at all — by design. Maybe the media wants to sell clicks, maybe too many politicians haven't studied history — who knows? The motives aren't the point. The point is just pragmatic.

    If you can't see this pattern, where is a society likely to end up? Well, at the end of the pattern. Ruled by the most insane among it. The most extreme, the most hostile, the most cruel, the most ignorant.

    Remember Soviet Russia and Nazi Germany? That is the way we're heading now, as a planet. Maybe we won't end up all the way down that road of darkness — but that's not saying much, is it? And so a big question for the world is this: who won't let themselves end up that way this decade?

    https://eand.co/why-the-world-is-going-insane-865517207d9c

    This is a

    new Diner page

    Logged in as:Guest
    Forum Home