Quote from: K-Dog on Aug 17, 2024, 03:48 PM

QuoteWhat does it mean to be a communist.  It means the working people taking collective responsibility for their country.

That is what Kyle is talking about.  What communist do you think he is talking about?

The kind that hasn't existed in reality yet. Hopes and dreams aren't a plan, nor are claims of outcomes not seen before in evidence in big communist countries, the USSR and ChiComs.

Can you point me at his discussion as to why other Communist systems turned out so poorly for the people or the country at large, and his PLAN as to why his new communism won't arrive at the same outcome?

Quote from: K-DogThis video is about America.  Tune in, your head is somewhere else.

America isn't communist. The American Communist Party isn't one I can vote for, nor does it advertise its advantages to capitalism locally, nor have I seen any claims it makes in the papers, on the TV at night, etc etc. Bashing America because you don't like the way it works is just bashing America, regardless of what political system you favor in its place. Its popular and easy. Discussing the details howeever...

Is it explained in the video by the American Communist Party how I will be affected by their PLAN to make the US communist? Are people with above average incomes to be taxed so everyone can have free health care? Will be housed in places where my neighbors might an Elon Musk folks on one side of a large concrete apartment complex and the other a family who thinks vodka and reefer cures all ills? What will happen to those who have accumulated wealth, will households with 7 figure housing equity be required to sell it to get to the expected level of housing as the rest of us? Can we all own multiple luxury cars, or only party leaders?

Quote from: K-DogConcerning the how, the answers are in the video.

If you tell me my obvious questions of a neophyte to the history of how countries transition from something not Communism to something Communism is in the video, I will watch it all, front to back.

If you, having watched the video, know it doesn't answer what strikes me as obvious questions that any new or potential party member might ask (and recruiters who know the story should have ready and easy answers for), then please venture that now. If you say that information is there and all it takes is the time to listen, I will find time tomorrow to watch it from to back.